First Baldwin Insurance, LLC

5.0 out of 5 stars

Mario G. - October 21, 2026

First Baldwin Insurance has been a trusted service provider for our home insurance since 2016. Our current agent, Sarah has been nothing short of spectacular. She searches for policies with companies which provide the service needed while saving me on the premium. And that’s something worth of praise and recognition. Thank you folks.

5.0 out of 5 stars

Donald W. - October 12, 2026

Very nice folks always friendly and available to help. They will be glad to furnish details on any insurance needs you have in a very timely matter.

5.0 out of 5 stars

Donald M. - October 8, 2026

Very professional and courteous!!

5.0 out of 5 stars

Debra S. - October 8, 2026

I have been pleased with the responsive service I have received and all my questions answered.

5.0 out of 5 stars

John S. - September 10, 2026

Staff was very friendly, professional and responded to our concerns.

4.0 out of 5 stars

Charles B. - September 7, 2026

Friendly folks, always do a good job for us. And local.

5.0 out of 5 stars

James F. - September 4, 2026

Awesome employees. They will work with you until the end. Great job to everyone. 😊

4.5 out of 5 stars

John C. - August 25, 2026

Sarah Killgore is our new agent now and she seems to be on the ball

5.0 out of 5 stars

Jason E. - August 25, 2026

I always have a great experience with First Baldwin Insurance. Special thanks to my agent Sarah Killgore. The staff is very friendly, professional and helpful. They took the time to answer my questions and made sure I understood everything about my coverage. I really appreciate the excellent customer service and how easy they made everything for me. I would definitely recommend First Baldwin Insurance to anyone looking for dependable insurance and great customer service!

5.0 out of 5 stars

Ronnie C. - August 20, 2026

Happy with them. Have been using them for insurance for over a decade and a half.

Sort Reviews by: Date or Rating

Leave Us a Review

We've found that customer reviews are very helpful in keeping our business thriving. We would truly appreciate a review from you!

Visit your preferred site to leave a review or comment:

Claims

If you have your policy information, you can file your claim directly with your carrier.

AIUA
866-780-2482
https://aiua.org/claims/new
claims@aiua.org

All Risks
800-366-5810 OPT 2
claims@allrisks.org

Allstar Underwriters Inc
ereport@natlclaim.com

American Bankers Insurance Co
800-224-4170
claims.department@assurant.com

American Modern
800-375-2075
ONLINE : www.amig.com

ASI
866-274-5677
ONLINE: https://americanstrategic.com/claims-center/report-a-claim
claims@asicorp.org

Aspera
804-289-1394

Assurant Flood Claims
800-423-4403
reportfloodclaim@assurant.com

Cabrillo Coastal
866-482-5246
claims@haborclaims.com
ONLINE : https://insured.cabgen.com/claimreport/

Centauri Specialty
New Claims: 877-234-4401
Existing Claims: 866-215-7574
Flood Claims: 888-481-1141
ONLINE : centauriinsurance.com/claims
Email: claims@centauri-ins.com

Foremost
800-527-3907

Frontline
866-673-0623
ONLINE : frontlineinsurance.com/file-a-claim

Gulf States/Coastal American
888-277-0575

Hartford Flood
800-787-5677
Claims@floodpro.net

Heritage Insurance
855-415-7120
claims@heritagepci.com

ICAT
866-789-4228
https://www.icat.com/claims/report-a-claim

Johnson & Johnson Insurance
800-487-7565 ext. 5024
claims@jjins.com

Kinsale
804-289-1394
newclaimnotices@kinsaleins.com

Markel (Evanston)
800-362-7535
https://www.markelinsurance.com/file-a-claim
newclaims@markel.com

National General Insurance
Flood: 888-598-0296
https://nationalgeneral.managemyfloodpolicy.com/
800-468-3466
https://claims.nationalgeneral.com/report
service@NGIC.com

Neptune
727-202-4815
https://neptuneflood.com/report-a-claim/#report-a-claim

NFIP Servicing Agent
800-767-4341
floodsmart@fema.dhs.gov