Overall Rating / 2037 Total 1st-Party Reviews

4.9 Out of
5 Stars

First Baldwin Insurance, LLC

5.0 out of 5 stars

Mario G. - October 21, 2026

First Baldwin Insurance has been a trusted service provider for our home insurance since 2016. Our current agent, Sarah has been nothing short of spectacular. She searches for policies with companies which provide the service needed while saving me on the premium. And that’s something worth of praise and recognition. Thank you folks.

5.0 out of 5 stars

Donald W. - October 12, 2026

Very nice folks always friendly and available to help. They will be glad to furnish details on any insurance needs you have in a very timely matter.

5.0 out of 5 stars

Donald M. - October 8, 2026

Very professional and courteous!!

5.0 out of 5 stars

Debra S. - October 8, 2026

I have been pleased with the responsive service I have received and all my questions answered.

5.0 out of 5 stars

John S. - September 10, 2026

Staff was very friendly, professional and responded to our concerns.

4.0 out of 5 stars

Charles B. - September 7, 2026

Friendly folks, always do a good job for us. And local.

5.0 out of 5 stars

James F. - September 4, 2026

Awesome employees. They will work with you until the end. Great job to everyone. 😊

4.5 out of 5 stars

John C. - August 25, 2026

Sarah Killgore is our new agent now and she seems to be on the ball

5.0 out of 5 stars

Jason E. - August 25, 2026

I always have a great experience with First Baldwin Insurance. Special thanks to my agent Sarah Killgore. The staff is very friendly, professional and helpful. They took the time to answer my questions and made sure I understood everything about my coverage. I really appreciate the excellent customer service and how easy they made everything for me. I would definitely recommend First Baldwin Insurance to anyone looking for dependable insurance and great customer service!

5.0 out of 5 stars

Ronnie C. - August 20, 2026

Happy with them. Have been using them for insurance for over a decade and a half.

Sort Reviews by: Date or Rating

Leave Us a Review

We've found that customer reviews are very helpful in keeping our business thriving. We would truly appreciate a review from you!

Visit your preferred site to leave a review or comment:

Business Insurance

Take a moment to feel the weight lifted off your shoulders. Imagine a team that truly listens, understands, and supports your needs. We’re not just guiding you through the uncertainties; they're forging a partnership rooted in trust and reliability. With our expertise and decided approach, you're free to focus on what matters most - nurturing your business and watching it flourish.

Business Insurance Coverage

Insurance Expertise

In our world, uncertainties can feel overwhelming. We're here to listen, understand, and support you every step of the way. Imagine a partnership where you feel empowered to face challenges head-on, knowing you have a reliable team by your side. Together, we'll navigate life's twists and turns, ensuring you feel secure and protected.

Learn more about our expertise

Individuals & Families

As you cherish the comfort of your home, the reliability of your car, and the growth of your livelihood, we're here to ensure they're protected. Count on us to listen, understand, and take action when you need us. With tailored policies and unwavering support, we're committed to enabling you to enjoy life's moments without worry. Trust us to be your partner, guiding you with empathy and persistence every step of the way. Rest assured; your security is our priority.

Personal Insurance Coverage

First Baldwin Insurance works for you – Serving Gulf Shores, Orange Beach & Foley, AL and all of Baldwin County!

Insurance & Risk Expertise Solutions for Companies & Individuals

Imagine having an insurance agent who understands your unique life—the ebbs and flows, the highs and lows. We’re not just there for you; we’re with you every step of the way. Visualize policies crafted to fit your requirements, like a safety net tailored to your needs. With us, it’s not just about coverage; it’s about peace of mind. So, you can live freely, knowing you’re protected, allowing you to focus on what matters most.

Personal Lines:

Homeowners Insurance
High-Value Homeowner’s Insurance
Multiple occupancy types – Primary, Secondary, Seasonal, and Tenant Occupied
Single Family, Multi-Family, and Condominium Insurance
Umbrella Insurance – $1 Million – $10 Million
Builder’s Risk Insurance: 3, 6, 9 & 12-month terms
Auto Insurance
Boat Insurance
Motorcycle Insurance
RV Insurance

Commercial Insurance:

General Liability Insurance – Residential & Commercial, General Contractors
Condominium Association Insurance
Restaurants/ Bars/ Taverns, Liquor Liability Insurance
Worker’s Compensation
Professional Liability Insurance, D&O and E&O Coverages
Commercial Umbrella Insurance – $1 Million – $10 Million
1-4 Family Rental Dwellings, Apartments, Condos
Manufacturing, Mercantile, Marinas
Builder’s Risk Insurance: 3, 6, 9, 12-month terms
Boats for Charter (fishing & touring)
Commercial Auto Insurance

Featured Insurance Carriers

We are the premier independent insurance agent located in Foley, Alabama, serving coastal Alabama and Florida. We specialize in homeowners and small business insurance coverage in the cities of Foley, Gulf Shores, Loxley, Elberta, Josephine, Stockton, Fairhope, Robertsdale, Summerdale, Silverhill, Perdido, Bay Minette, Orange Beach, Lillian, Point Clear, Stapleton, Daphne, Spanish Fort, Magnolia Springs, and Bon Secour, Alabama and the cities of Pensacola, Navarre, Gulf Breeze, Destin, Panama City, Ft. Myers, Boca Grande, Useppa Island, North Captiva Island, and Sanabel/Captiva, Florida.